Yes. I once was driving a nondescript, Chevy compact car with Colorado plates as a rental in San Bernadino, CA. When I came out of a busy mall where I'd stopped, I went to an identical Chevy, again with Colorado plates.
As I was trying to figure out why my key wasn't opening the door, I heard a booming voice say, "What the f*#k are you doing to my car?" I turned to see a very large man, and he didn't look happy.
He looked unimpressed when I explained I had mistaken his car for my rental. Just when I figured he was going hit me, he pointed to a car a few spaces behind his car and said, "You better hope your key opens that door." Thankfully that was my car.