That's the frosting on that cupcake you're eating....It's orange!
LOL! I went with ONE simple, common item this round! lol Although I'm sure these also represent simple, common, items, they are not "it". lolView attachment 5395 A dog coffee cup with a staw and neosporin inside.
View attachment 5402
OK, this was the first object in the box....finally got a pic of it.
As I said, the NEW object in the box is an everyday, common item. So far, nobody has had a hit. Keep trying!