Is it dinner or supper and why?

[jadamz]

Why do older people use the word “dinner” for “lunch” while younger people use “dinner” for “supper”? When did this change, or is this a regional phenomenon?
I keep having to explain this. It must no longer be taught.
OK
Breakfast is ‘break the fast’ and a fast is a time of not-eating. You don’t eat while you are asleep, so ‘breakfast’ the meal is always the first meal of the day.
Lunch is at midday.
Supper is the LAST meal of the day. There used to be a time when people ate four times a day - and supper is always the last and latest meal.
DINNER however, is not tied to a time of day.
DINNER is the LARGEST meal you eat during the day.
So sometimes ‘dinner’ is at lunchtime, and sometimes ‘dinner’ is at suppertime. Because breakfast time and lunchtime and suppertime are TIMES, but ‘dinner’ is a size of meal.
That said - in CURRENT American culture, the largest meal of the day is often at suppertime, so supper = dinner to a LOT of people, even though that is not exactly true. So starting - probably - around 40 or 50 years ago, people started saying ‘dinnertime’ and they meant ‘in the evening’.
I heard that sometimes when I was young (I am old enough to remember this) but it was still pretty clear that DINNER was simply AT suppertime, not that supper was invariably dinner.
In fact, on Sunday, DINNER was specifically at LUNCH time, and ‘Sunday dinner’ was a real event, which took place sometime between noon and one o’clock.
Thanksgiving ‘dinner’ is also typically in early afternoon (‘lunchtime’) as is ‘Christmas dinner’.
DINNER is your largest meal. Supper is in the evening.
If your largest meal of the day is always at the last meal of the day, then your supper is your dinner.
Edit to add: apparently some people like a reference ALSO, rather than trust that someone who answers knows whereof they speak. So here:


Definition of DINNER
the principal meal of the day; a formal feast or banquet; table d'hôte… See the full definition
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/dinner

 

[7Critter]

I totally agree. Yesterday, I had Christmas dinner, which was also my supper at around 4:30 pm

 

[Debi]

Why do older people use the word “dinner” for “lunch” while younger people use “dinner” for “supper”? When did this change, or is this a regional phenomenon?
I keep having to explain this. It must no longer be taught.
OK
Breakfast is ‘break the fast’ and a fast is a time of not-eating. You don’t eat while you are asleep, so ‘breakfast’ the meal is always the first meal of the day.
Lunch is at midday.
Supper is the LAST meal of the day. There used to be a time when people ate four times a day - and supper is always the last and latest meal.
DINNER however, is not tied to a time of day.
DINNER is the LARGEST meal you eat during the day.
So sometimes ‘dinner’ is at lunchtime, and sometimes ‘dinner’ is at suppertime. Because breakfast time and lunchtime and suppertime are TIMES, but ‘dinner’ is a size of meal.
That said - in CURRENT American culture, the largest meal of the day is often at suppertime, so supper = dinner to a LOT of people, even though that is not exactly true. So starting - probably - around 40 or 50 years ago, people started saying ‘dinnertime’ and they meant ‘in the evening’.
I heard that sometimes when I was young (I am old enough to remember this) but it was still pretty clear that DINNER was simply AT suppertime, not that supper was invariably dinner.
In fact, on Sunday, DINNER was specifically at LUNCH time, and ‘Sunday dinner’ was a real event, which took place sometime between noon and one o’clock.
Thanksgiving ‘dinner’ is also typically in early afternoon (‘lunchtime’) as is ‘Christmas dinner’.
DINNER is your largest meal. Supper is in the evening.
If your largest meal of the day is always at the last meal of the day, then your supper is your dinner.
Edit to add: apparently some people like a reference ALSO, rather than trust that someone who answers knows whereof they speak. So here:
Definition of DINNER
the principal meal of the day; a formal feast or banquet; table d'hôte… See the full definition
Definition of DINNER

Finally! An answer to the ongoing debate!!!

 

[Duke]

Why do older people use the word “dinner” for “lunch” while younger people use “dinner” for “supper”? When did this change, or is this a regional phenomenon?
I keep having to explain this. It must no longer be taught.
OK
Breakfast is ‘break the fast’ and a fast is a time of not-eating. You don’t eat while you are asleep, so ‘breakfast’ the meal is always the first meal of the day.
Lunch is at midday.
Supper is the LAST meal of the day. There used to be a time when people ate four times a day - and supper is always the last and latest meal.
DINNER however, is not tied to a time of day.
DINNER is the LARGEST meal you eat during the day.
So sometimes ‘dinner’ is at lunchtime, and sometimes ‘dinner’ is at suppertime. Because breakfast time and lunchtime and suppertime are TIMES, but ‘dinner’ is a size of meal.
That said - in CURRENT American culture, the largest meal of the day is often at suppertime, so supper = dinner to a LOT of people, even though that is not exactly true. So starting - probably - around 40 or 50 years ago, people started saying ‘dinnertime’ and they meant ‘in the evening’.
I heard that sometimes when I was young (I am old enough to remember this) but it was still pretty clear that DINNER was simply AT suppertime, not that supper was invariably dinner.
In fact, on Sunday, DINNER was specifically at LUNCH time, and ‘Sunday dinner’ was a real event, which took place sometime between noon and one o’clock.
Thanksgiving ‘dinner’ is also typically in early afternoon (‘lunchtime’) as is ‘Christmas dinner’.
DINNER is your largest meal. Supper is in the evening.
If your largest meal of the day is always at the last meal of the day, then your supper is your dinner.
Edit to add: apparently some people like a reference ALSO, rather than trust that someone who answers knows whereof they speak. So here:
Definition of DINNER
the principal meal of the day; a formal feast or banquet; table d'hôte… See the full definition
Definition of DINNER

Ok, what about "tea" in the UK, Oz, and such countries? From these definitions, looks like tea corresponds with supper.

 

[Debi]

Ok, what about "tea" in the UK, Oz, and such countries? From these definitions, looks like tea corresponds with supper.

 

[WitchAndShaman]

My question J is, “Is it eatable?”

If so then dine on!

 

[Paintman]

When I try to keep my calorie amount about the same spread out between five meals - is that 5 dinners ?
Or one breakfast and four dinners ?

 

[Debi]

When I try to keep my calorie amount about the same spread out between five meals - is that 5 dinners ?
Or one breakfast and four dinners ?

You must be a Hobbit....first breakfast, second breakfast, etc.

 

[7Critter]

You must be a Hobbit....first breakfast, second breakfast, etc.

It does keep the metabolism running high

 

[Debi]