Gene hacking backfire

Debi

Owner/Admin
Staff
Joined
Sep 16, 2013
Messages
241,607
Reaction score
234,289
Points
315
Location
South of Indy
A Trial That Gene-Hacked Mosquitoes to Stop Breeding Has Backfired Spectacularly

On its surface, the plan was simple: gene-hack mosquitoes so their offspring immediately die, mix them with disease-spreading bugs in the wild, and watch the population drop off. Unfortunately, that didn't quite pan out.

The genetically-altered mosquitoes did mix with the wild population, and for a brief period the number of mosquitoes in Jacobino, Brazil did plummet, according to research published in Nature Scientific Reports last week.

But 18 months later the population bounced right back up, New Atlas reports - and even worse, the new genetic hybrids may be even more resilient to future attempts to quell their numbers.

Desperate Times
Mosquitoes capable of transmitting dangerous diseases like Zika, dengue, and malaria are spreading farther than ever, thanks to global climate change. To combat them, scientists have sometimes tried to alter the bugs' genetics so that they couldn't reproduce.

"The claim was that genes from the release strain would not get into the general population because offspring would die," Yale researcher Jeffrey Powell, one of the researchers behind the new paper, told New Atlas. "That obviously was not what happened."

Playing God
In Brazil, the wild mosquitoes mated with the gene-hacked population and created a new sort of genetic hybrid that's more robust than the wild bugs were.

While the new variant isn't inherently dangerous - or at least not additionally so - the scientists behind the project say they don't fully understand how things will change for future generations.

"It is the unanticipated outcome that is concerning," Powell told New Atlas.
 
Can somebody sue these twits for genetic terrorism before they do anything more serious?

They have now created a more resistant mosquito and released it into the wild.
 
why can't they just find out the mosquitoes natural predators? Like bats for instance, and take it from there? It reminds me of the lantern fly situation we have here in PA. They are decimating lots of flora, and lay eggs just anyplace. They like to eat lots of things,not just one or two, and I cannot understand why these scientists are stymied. :confused:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lynne and Debi
why can't they just find out the mosquitoes natural predators? Like bats for instance, and take it from there? It reminds me of the lantern fly situation we have here in PA. They are decimating lots of flora, and lay eggs just anyplace. They like to eat lots of things,not just one or two, and I cannot understand why these scientists are stymied. :confused:
Because they believe they can do it better than nature. Obviously not, but they sure believe it.
 
Because they believe they can do it better than nature. Obviously not, but they sure believe it.
I found this old book that was published in the 1970's, and there were so many cool solutions to many things like getting rid of unwanted pests and such. And not one of them involved chemicals or playing God. Common sense seems to be in short supply!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lynne and Debi
I
A Trial That Gene-Hacked Mosquitoes to Stop Breeding Has Backfired Spectacularly

On its surface, the plan was simple: gene-hack mosquitoes so their offspring immediately die, mix them with disease-spreading bugs in the wild, and watch the population drop off. Unfortunately, that didn't quite pan out.

The genetically-altered mosquitoes did mix with the wild population, and for a brief period the number of mosquitoes in Jacobino, Brazil did plummet, according to research published in Nature Scientific Reports last week.

But 18 months later the population bounced right back up, New Atlas reports - and even worse, the new genetic hybrids may be even more resilient to future attempts to quell their numbers.

Desperate Times
Mosquitoes capable of transmitting dangerous diseases like Zika, dengue, and malaria are spreading farther than ever, thanks to global climate change. To combat them, scientists have sometimes tried to alter the bugs' genetics so that they couldn't reproduce.

"The claim was that genes from the release strain would not get into the general population because offspring would die," Yale researcher Jeffrey Powell, one of the researchers behind the new paper, told New Atlas. "That obviously was not what happened."

Playing God
In Brazil, the wild mosquitoes mated with the gene-hacked population and created a new sort of genetic hybrid that's more robust than the wild bugs were.

While the new variant isn't inherently dangerous - or at least not additionally so - the scientists behind the project say they don't fully understand how things will change for future generations.

"It is the unanticipated outcome that is concerning," Powell told New Atlas.[/QUOT
A Trial That Gene-Hacked Mosquitoes to Stop Breeding Has Backfired Spectacularly

On its surface, the plan was simple: gene-hack mosquitoes so their offspring immediately die, mix them with disease-spreading bugs in the wild, and watch the population drop off. Unfortunately, that didn't quite pan out.

The genetically-altered mosquitoes did mix with the wild population, and for a brief period the number of mosquitoes in Jacobino, Brazil did plummet, according to research published in Nature Scientific Reports last week.

But 18 months later the population bounced right back up, New Atlas reports - and even worse, the new genetic hybrids may be even more resilient to future attempts to quell their numbers.

Desperate Times
Mosquitoes capable of transmitting dangerous diseases like Zika, dengue, and malaria are spreading farther than ever, thanks to global climate change. To combat them, scientists have sometimes tried to alter the bugs' genetics so that they couldn't reproduce.

"The claim was that genes from the release strain would not get into the general population because offspring would die," Yale researcher Jeffrey Powell, one of the researchers behind the new paper, told New Atlas. "That obviously was not what happened."

Playing God
In Brazil, the wild mosquitoes mated with the gene-hacked population and created a new sort of genetic hybrid that's more robust than the wild bugs were.

While the new variant isn't inherently dangerous - or at least not additionally so - the scientists behind the project say they don't fully understand how things will change for future generations.

"It is the unanticipated outcome that is concerning," Powell told New Atlas.

I don't understand.

What's wrong with mosquito nets?
And just plain not littering?

And if they MUST do genetic engineering, why a group that kills the offsprings?
I mean, that's sure to create a resilient bunch. Evolution.

They could've just made one that doesn't transmit the disease.
 
  • Like
Reactions: garnetsilver